Feeding
People should not feed mute swans. Any feeding of wildlife makes the animals feel safe and encourages them, and the impacts they cause, to remain in the area. If a bird feeder is available for songbirds and mute swans are in the area, then the area below the feeder will likely also attract swans. To discourage mute swans, consider taking the feeder down for two to three weeks to encourage mute swans to disperse. Signs can be installed where mute swans are present to communicate that feeding of mute swans is not allowed. Signs are most successful if they describe the negative effects of feeding mute swans and rules against feeding are enforced.
Abatement
Abatement techniques are non-lethal methods used to frighten and discourage mute swans from an area. These techniques will generally send mute swans to other places where they will continue to reproduce and have destructive impacts. Different management methods can entail audial, visual, and physical techniques as long as local ordinances are followed.
Abatement techniques will only be as effective as the amount of effort employed. Abatement must be used repetitively as soon as mute swans appear in the area because mute swans are much more difficult to frighten after they feel comfortable in a location. Also, the effectiveness of abatement greatly decreases if mute swans are fed by people in the area.
The following techniques may be used to disperse mute swans, where safe and legal to do so. Check local ordinances and laws before using techniques. No permits are required to use the following techniques.
- Audial Devices
- Air horns
- Whistles
- Blank pistols
- Specialized projectiles (bangers, screamers, and whistlers)
- Cracker shells from a shotgun
- Firecrackers
- Propane cannons
- Visual Devices
- Predator decoys
- Scarecrows
- Hand-held green lasers
- Physical
- Dogs (chasing only)
- Chase boats
- Nest destruction (before egg laying)
- Temporary exclusion methods to discourage use of nesting locations (permits required on public waters)
Permits
Abatement techniques are not a form of mute swan population control but rather send the problem to another area. If abatement techniques are not effective, other options are available for managing mute swan populations.
DNR will issue free permits to lake or homeowner associations to legally take mute swans, render eggs incapable of hatching, or destroy nests on public lakes. Resident landowners and tenants do not need a permit from the DNR to take mute swans that are causing damage or posing a health or safety threat to people or domestic animals on land or private water that they own or lease, following local ordinances. A permit is also not necessary to disperse the swans, provided they are not harmed.
- Nest and Egg Destruction
Nest removal can be carried out without a permit at any time that no eggs are present. Repeatedly destroying nests can encourage breeding mute swans to relocate, build a new nest, or nest later in the season. It is advisable and most effective to start nest removal as soon as swans are seen scouting nest locations. Nest construction may last for several weeks, and the first egg may be laid less than 24 hours after the nest is constructed. Once the first egg is laid in a nest, verify below if a permit is needed from Indiana DNR before taking further nest removal action.
A resident landowner can remove nests and their eggs from their own private property without a permit or permission from Indiana DNR at any time. For swan nests with eggs on commonly held or shared property, a government authority, lake association or local property owners association should seek a permit through Indiana DNR to destroy nests that have eggs in them. The eggs must be destroyed by individuals approved by the permittee. A permit can only be issued to someone with legal authority at the given property (e.g., HOA, Property Manager, Parks Director, etc.).
Once a permit is obtained, egg treatment or nest destruction can occur. Be cautious if attempting to conduct these activities without some form of protection. Mute swans are aggressive during the nesting period and may attack a person who comes close to their nest. Timing of egg destruction is important to ensure humane treatment of eggs. If you are unsure how long a mute swan has been incubating eggs, use the “float test.” Take the eggs and put them in a bucket with at least 6 inches of water. Young eggs that are not well developed will sink. These eggs should be addled and returned to the nest for additional incubation and checked again in another week. Eggs that are further along in development will float. Eggs that float without tilting can be addled and removed from the nest. Eggs that are floating and tilting are likely on the verge of hatching and should be placed back in the nest.
When dealing with a nest with newly laid eggs, a person who has eggs on private property or who has obtained a permit for public areas may either shake each egg for at least 60 seconds (until they hear a sloshing sound), puncture the large end of the egg with a sharp object, or coat the egg with 100% corn oil. All these methods, collectively known as addling, will prevent eggs from developing, and they will not hatch. Addled eggs should be placed back into the nest so that the mute swan will continue to incubate the eggs. If the eggs are removed or broken early in the incubation period, then the mute swan may re-nest and lay more eggs.
If eggs are not rendered incapable of hatching through addling, the eggs and nest can be destroyed, but only if they are late in the incubation period. If a nesting mute swan has invested a long period in incubating eggs and they are removed, then she will probably not have the energy to re-nest. Incubation of roughly three weeks may be a long enough period so that new eggs will not be laid. Mute swan egg incubation ranges from 34 to 41 days, so don’t wait too long before destroying eggs.
- Removal of Birds
An aggressive egg destruction initiative will only at best maintain the current mute swan population level. As a result, the ecological damage and the human and wildlife conflicts that mute swans cause will continue. Removing mute swans from where they have established populations is the only way to lessen their negative impact.
Mute swans can be legally taken by a resident landowner or tenant on property or a pond that they own or lease without a permit, following local ordinances.
For mute swans in public spaces, public waters, or spaces with multiple landownerships, a permit must be secured to lethally take mute swans. The lake association, local property owners association, or landowner group can seek a permit through Indiana DNR to euthanize the adults (and young if present). The swans must be euthanized by individuals approved by the community. A permit can only be issued to someone with the legal authority at the property in question (HOA, property manager, etc.). Because mute swans are an invasive species and can create conflicts, the DNR recommends euthanizing mute swans instead of relocating them.
