Length is about 5.5 to 7.5 miles, depending on route chosen. The Spurgeon Hollow Trailhead is next to Spurgeon Hollow Lake, 2 miles east of S.R. 135, northeast of Salem. The trail leads southeast from the trailhead parking lot along the north shore of the lake, which is available for fishing. Within 0.5 mile, the hiker has a choice of two routes as the trail makes a loop of about 8 miles through the backcountry area. The northern leg of the loop takes the hiker on a moderately rugged, ridge-top hike of about 5 miles. It adds more than 2 miles to the length of this segment. The southern leg runs about 3 miles through a moist valley. This segment is easy walking. The northern and southern legs that form the loop are also part of Forestry trails and are marked with blue blazes. The white Knobstone blazes should also be visible. The trail continues to the south from the southeast corner of the backcountry loop.
After leaving the backcountry area, the trail heads south and crosses a gravel road turning east 0.1 mile to a small wildlife pond. The trail winds around the pond and continues east, crossing a creek several times, then crossing Pull Tight Road and then New Cut Road. It turns east and rises to a ridge top, coming up on another gravel road, Banes Hollow Road, and the Oxley Trailhead.
To drive from the Spurgeon Hollow Trailhead to the John Stuart Oxley Memorial Trailhead, turn south on Delaney Creek Road. Go south until Delaney Creek intersects with Evelyn Jackson Road and turn east. The road curves southeast and becomes Nicholson Hollow Road. Follow this road for about 2.5 miles until it makes a sharp left curve. Continue for about 1.5 miles until the t intersection with West Point Road. Turn south on West Point and continue for about a mile. Then, turn east onto Banes Hollow Road. The trailhead is about a mile down the road.